By Deborah G. Mayo, Rachelle D. Hollander

Discussions of technology and values in danger administration have mostly enthusiastic about how values input into arguments approximately hazards, that's, problems with appropriate chance. in its place this quantity concentrates on how values input into gathering, examining, speaking, and comparing the facts of dangers, that's, problems with the acceptability of proof of possibility. via concentrating on appropriate facts, this quantity avoids obstacles to growth. One barrier assumes that facts of chance is essentially an issue of goal clinical information and consequently uncontroversial. the opposite assumes that facts of threat, being "just" an issue of values, isn't really amenable to reasoned critique. Denying either extremes, this quantity argues for a extra confident end: figuring out the interrelations of clinical and price concerns permits a serious scrutiny of possibility tests and higher public deliberation approximately social offerings. The members, uncommon philosophers, coverage analysts, and usual and social scientists, study environmental and clinical controversies, and assumptions underlying perspectives approximately hazard review and the medical and statistical types utilized in danger administration.

Show description

Read Online or Download Acceptable Evidence: Science and Values in Risk Management (Environmental Ethics and Science Policy Series) PDF

Similar environmental policy books

U.S. Environmental Policy and Politics: A Documentary History

As electorate handle the problems of weather swap, earth-friendly applied sciences, and jumpstarting a eco-friendly financial system, environmental politics has won a famous place at the American political panorama. "U. S. Environmental coverage and Politics: A Documentary background" exhibits readers the various methods all through American historical past during which environmental matters have intersected with problems with power construction and intake, executive legislation, deepest estate rights, fiscal progress, and way of life offerings.

Globalization and the environment: greening global political economy

This groundbreaking research brings jointly fiscal globalization and the surroundings as by no means prior to. Gabriela Kutting argues for an "eco-holistic" procedure that merges social, political, fiscal, and environmental research, in order that a globalizing political economic climate should be understood relating to environmental and social issues.

Exploring sustainable consumption: environmental policy and the social sciences

Consumerism is more and more well-known as an important drain on worldwide assets and the quest for sustainable intake is rising as a key coverage factor. this article locates the matter inside a selected historical past and recruits professional evaluations from numerous disciplines.

Higher Education for Sustainable Development

This publication asks how better schooling should still technique the duty of teaching for sustainability after which units to answering it. It presents a advisor when you suggest for sustainability and should you don't and makes some degree of emphasising that each one in greater schooling have the capability and willingness to give a contribution not directly.

Extra info for Acceptable Evidence: Science and Values in Risk Management (Environmental Ethics and Science Policy Series)

Example text

These initiatives bolstered the EPA's scientific credibility but ultimately had little influence on the agency's decision making: The pharmacokinetics panel supported the EPA's judgment that the CIIT's research was not yet sufficiently validated for use in policy-relevant risk assessments (EPA 1987). Although the review by the expert panel permitted the EPA to continue using its established principles of risk assessment, not all observers were persuaded of the correctness of the agency's final decision.

Although the hazards of lead have been long known and documented (Nriagu 1983), the hazards for children were allowed to exist and even grow for decades before effective action was taken. Both children and women have traditionally spent much more time in the home than have adult men, but only recently has indoor pollution been recognized as a serious source of contaminants. The household, not officially recognized as a workplace in the United States, does not come under OSHA's jurisdiction. It has received from the EPA little attention as an element of a public environment to be protected, although recent warnings on radon may signal a change.

Will the quantification of essentially subjective judgments convey a false sense of precision regarding expert opinion? Will the use of a complex statistical technique enhance the policymaker's understanding of the relevant scientific issues, or will it induce undue deference and transfer too much control over risk management to technical experts? A SYSTEM OF TRUST Britain's philosophy for dealing with uncertainty in policy-relevant science offers in many respects a perfect counterfoil to that of the United States, and many of its distinctive attributes are reflected in the work of that country's prestigious Royal Commissions.

Download PDF sample

Acceptable Evidence: Science and Values in Risk Management by Deborah G. Mayo, Rachelle D. Hollander
Rated 4.54 of 5 – based on 45 votes